question about copyright and code, is this legal?
Patrik Stridvall
ps at leissner.se
Mon Oct 13 04:20:51 CDT 2003
> > Protecting trivially collectable collections of fact would serve
> > no purpose that I can see...
>
> Here, if the collection as a whole requires trivial effort to
> collect, it's
> not protected. It's the aggregate effort that counts. The
> problem with the MS
> tables is that from what has been said the aggregate has
> involved a lot of
> effort over many years.
Perhaps.
However:
1. The data in question is of a more scientific in nature than the facts
about the world that law is presumably ment to protect so it might
not apply at all.
2. Since Microsoft have intentionally published it in the US where no
such protection exists, it could be argued that it have exhausted its
right to protection because of this. After all everybody could import
it itself from the US if they wanted. In the case of Wine and other
open source software this is especially true because of the Internet.
More information about the wine-devel
mailing list