appdb rating inflation

[Remco]

What about a checklist of problems it doesn't have, and basing the rating on that.

Something like:

Installation:
(_) Installs correctly.
(_) No installation nessecary to run.
(_) Preinstalled on Windows.
(x) Doesn't install.

[_] Works without an unofficially patched Wine.
[_] Works without a compatibility mode different from XP.
[_] Works without a registry setting.
[_] Works without a crack.
[_] Works without a setting in winecfg.

(_) Works without glitches.
(_) Has minor graphical glitches.
(_) Minor Functional problems
(_) Doesn't work as expected.

Execution:
[_] Works without an unofficially patched Wine.

[_] Works without a compatibility mode different from XP.

[_] Works without a registry setting.

[_] Works without a crack.

[_] Works without a setting in winecfg.



(_) Works without glitches.

(_) Has minor graphical glitches.

(_) Minor Functional problems

(x) Doesn't work as expected.

If any isn't answered satisfactorily, it isn't Platina anymore. It is set up so that if you don't take the time to read it through, it will rate as Garbage.


__________________________________________________
Do You Yahoo!?
Tired of spam?  Yahoo! Mail has the best spam protection around 
http://mail.yahoo.com