[2/3] gdiplus: fix GdipPathIterNextMarker behaviour on path without markers. fix tests.

Reece Dunn msclrhd at googlemail.com
Sun Jul 13 04:20:45 CDT 2008

2008/7/13 Nikolay Sivov <bunglehead at gmail.com>:
> What do you think about matrix comparison or in general float comparison
> implementation? What is the best way to implement this. We have two
> cases now:
> 1. GdipIsMatrixEqual which compares two matrices (with simple bitwise
> operation now)

Is this the way it works on Windows? You have 4 basic cases:
a.  exactly equal;
b.  equal + epsilon for rounding/representation errors;
c.  equal - epsilon for rounding/representation errors;
d.  not equal.

The code at the moment covers a and d (is there a test for d?), but
what about b and c? These would be useful, because if the Windows
version of GdipIsMatrixEqual *is* catering for error of a given
epsilon, then you can use that function for validation. If not, you
have tests that prove that Windows is using a simplistic comparison

> 2. GdipIsMatrixInvertible which contains a check for 'not above zero'
> determinant.

It has been a while since I have done any matrix math. I'll assume
that the above is the correct definition/check for invertible (makes
sense because you have inv(a(ij)) = a(ij)/det(A), so can't have det(A)
== 0).

Now here, you have several 'classes' of matrices w.r.t. whether they
are invertible or not:
a.  det(A) > 0
b.  det(A) == 0
c.  det(A) < 0

So does Windows match your assumption for the answer to these (a ==>
yes; b, c ==> no).

> I think first of all we should choose an appropriate method to do so and
> only after that try to compare results with native. What do you think of
> that?

Are you saying that GdipIsMatrixInvertible should be used for
comparison of two matrices? If so, you can have two different matrices
that are invertible, so it does not make sense.

A good first step would be to print out the expected and returned
values for the matrices, and keep the GdipIsMatrixEqual check. This
will allow you to determine if the reason this is failing is due to
rounding errors, or that they are completely different results.

- Reece

More information about the wine-devel mailing list