[PATCH 2/2 v3] user32: Add more dialog creation message tests

Piotr Caban piotr at codeweavers.com
Wed Feb 17 03:50:56 CST 2016


On 17/02/16 10:37, Dmitry Timoshkov wrote:
>>>> On 02/16/16 14:08, Dmitry Timoshkov wrote:
>>>>> It's getting better, but again doesn't show a lot of details. Please add
>>>>> parameters for most of the recorded messages in the sequence, in particular
>>>>> EM_SETSEL and WM_GETDLGCODE are the mandatory ones. Also, in order to see
>>>>> the origin of EM_SETSEL I'd suggest to call DefDlgProc() manually and use
>>>>> defwndproc_counter around it together with the defwinproc flag.
>>>> DefDlgProc can't be called manually in this case. There are already some
>>>> comments about it in the tests.
>>> TestDlgProcA() calls DefDlgProc() this way without any problem.
>> It's because this test is using CreateWindow function family instead of
>> CreateDialog*.
> Then please create a window for testing using a way that is appropriate
> for your testing purposes and that allows using DefDlgProc().
You're not paying much attention to what's in the patch. I'm modifying 
part of CreateDialog function so it can't be tested if CreateWindow is 
used.
> Many of the tests in msg.c and win.c are created by me, I know the related
> code in user32 pretty well, and based on my knowledge I can't agree that
> your change is obvious, at least it's absolutely not obvious to me. Focus
> handling is very fragile part of user32 code, there are applications that
> are very sensitive to any change in that area, and it's very easy to break
> them. Please take time to create a more convincing set of tests.
I'm not changing anything focus related. I'm just adding text selection 
to code that was already setting focus.



More information about the wine-devel mailing list