[PATCH v2] shlwapi/tests: Document where SHFormatDateTimeA() crashes for NULL pointers.

Huw Davies huw at codeweavers.com
Thu Sep 2 04:13:22 CDT 2021


On Thu, Sep 02, 2021 at 11:44:36AM +0300, Saulius Krasuckas wrote:
> I agree. But for example when I tried to extend the LZOpenFile[AW] tests, I
> went for testing all combinations of wrong arguments I could imagine (still
> unfinished). That's because this way I could know more about the internal
> flow/branching of the black-boxed code.
> 
> I mean, if some questions arises about when that input pointer is handled
> (before other argument validation or maybe after that, or maybe at the end),
> the crash (and maybe additional crashes) would give some insights about the
> original algorithm.

Which is exactly why you should *not* write these sort of tests.
We're aiming to match the functionality of the API without copying its
implementation.  We don't want to know about its internal branching
structure.

Of course if a particular app depends on Windows returning a specific
error code then thats the time to add a test for it.

Huw.



More information about the wine-devel mailing list