Wine in Tango

Scott Ritchie scott at open-vote.org
Mon Sep 21 07:19:17 CDT 2009


Ralf Jung wrote:
> Hi everyone,
> 
>> I don't know if we can say this.  Only when our Wine-supplied icons are
>> appearing near application-supplied icons do we gain some consistency by
>> mimicing Windows style, but that consistency is confined to that
>> particular app.  Most icons the user sees are instead going to be
>> compared with the rest of the desktop and its applications, and adopting
>> a Tango style rather than a Windows style is the only way to get that
>> overall consistency.
> 
>> If we're not careful, Wine apps may continue to stick out rather than be
>> just another part of the desktop.
> If wine should integrate well with the surrounding Linux desktop, why don't you use the desktop icon set where possible? By using the Tango icons, wine applications will still stick out on almost all non-Gnome system (most notably KDE) as well as those Gnome desktops where the icon set was changed - that's not what I would call integration. I agree that the Tango icons are prettier than the one currently used, and as a result an improvement, but unfortunately they won't fix the "sticking out".
> 
> Kind regards,
> Ralf Jung

It's true, not everyone is using Tango, but it's the closest thing we
have to a standard.  It certainly wouldn't hurt to make Wine compatible
with multiple icon sets and then let packagers choose which one to use,
so I could provide a Gnome-wine and a KDE-wine and so on.

Starting with Tango seems like the best first bet though.

Thanks,
Scott Ritchie



More information about the wine-devel mailing list