Thursday, June 29, 2006, 12:02:38 PM, William Knop wrote:
On 6/29/06, Vincent Povirk
<madewokherd+d41d(a)gmail.com> wrote:
> On 6/29/06, Chris <chris.kcat(a)gmail.com> wrote:
> > One could argue Windows itself is a mis-feature. :P Isn't the point of Wine
to
> > duplicate Windows, feature-for-feature and bug-for-bug? IMO, autorun
> > capabilities should be included, though I personally don't care if it's
on or
> > off by default, as long as there's an option in winecfg. I'll just turn
it
> > off myself. Or perhaps even a popup notification upon the first detected
> > autorun-capable disc, asking if you want to turn autorun on or off.
> > autorun.inf needs to be parsed anyway, since it can set an icon for the
> > drive.
> No, I think the point of Wine is to run Windows programs on top of
> Unix. We don't need autorun to run Windows programs at all. Wine often
> leaves out features that are in Windows because they aren't needed to
> get Windows programs to run.
>
> Running whatever code happens to be on a cd without asking the user is
> a very bad idea. I don't want to see it happen, and I think most real
> Wine devs probably feel the same way.
>
> Gnome already has a feature that can ask the user what to do when a cd
> is inserted. KDE probably has a similar feature. I think they'd be the
> people to ask if you want something like Windows' autorun.
Having the ability to autorun cds is most definitely
not a misfeature.
Of course it's not. It's the perfect means of distributing
trojans, backdoors,
rootkits and other very useful software an every CD, including DVDs and music
CDs.
Vitaliy.